{ "scope": "one-sided occlusion residual; three synthetic scene layouts", "source_commit": "a2e22ce5e61ce6cf580ebb682d503a1b1078ef89", "plan_sha256": "8ee4b518ad87b4fb0b011fc80ef8bf3ccf1b3789c7ee005fe5151af70bdff7c4", "cases": [ { "scene": "original", "condition": "exact_z_visible", "sign": 1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.18270256994648235, -0.12331060701286084, 0.32183787591115076 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.016878684190050734, -0.025161243192804467, 0.009571499856813138, 0.9994950766519544 ] }, "delta": [ -1.1009806020994566, 0.5823695149495067, -0.7152403171988376, -0.16729743005351763, 0.07668939298713917, -0.07816212408884923 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 127, "nfev": 25, "njev": 17, "initial_support": [ 3746, 3738, 3747 ], "final_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 41.32721284560776, "optimality": 0.6538644215002306 }, "seconds": 0.21427602699259296, "population": [ { "points": 3783, "supported": 3783, "behind_over_20cm": 15, "in_front_over_20cm": 35 }, { "points": 3776, "supported": 3776, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 36 }, { "points": 3780, "supported": 3780, "behind_over_20cm": 14, "in_front_over_20cm": 43 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.14150116020117762, "translation_m": 0.03632462401835967, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.19833260555844226, -0.1402769275322355, 0.3275911218886859 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.015830190450380623, -0.02609967745875607, 0.009224861193765812, 0.9994914275984609 ] }, "delta": [ -1.217637055628081, 0.47288535661734526, -0.7608505870570835, -0.15166739444155772, 0.0597230724677645, -0.07240887811131415 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 187, "nfev": 31, "njev": 26, "initial_support": [ 3746, 3738, 3747 ], "final_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 29.322687579170353, "optimality": 0.01680108119116884 }, "seconds": 0.3338638860004721, "population": [ { "points": 3783, "supported": 3783, "behind_over_20cm": 35, "in_front_over_20cm": 30 }, { "points": 3776, "supported": 3776, "behind_over_20cm": 29, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 }, { "points": 3780, "supported": 3780, "behind_over_20cm": 26, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.21159221264982878, "translation_m": 0.04884957628001506, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "original", "condition": "exact_z_visible", "sign": -1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.18281353499514888, -0.12398255795745033, 0.3217080645135767 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.016849870394859082, -0.025162733998365373, 0.009564569389704437, 0.9994955916349975 ] }, "delta": [ 0.8981788288216301, -0.4150935041133544, 0.7853579062825725, 0.13281353499514886, -0.12398255795745033, 0.12170806451357669 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 111, "nfev": 21, "njev": 15, "initial_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "final_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 41.329115474561306, "optimality": 0.04393899236581614 }, "seconds": 0.21107056000619195, "population": [ { "points": 3783, "supported": 3783, "behind_over_20cm": 15, "in_front_over_20cm": 35 }, { "points": 3776, "supported": 3776, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 36 }, { "points": 3780, "supported": 3780, "behind_over_20cm": 14, "in_front_over_20cm": 45 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.14328813529627504, "translation_m": 0.03663028433511055, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.19859356758913926, -0.1384975706685253, 0.3270500515915785 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01594669745429724, -0.026116943716721484, 0.009264329038208279, 0.9994887594658934 ] }, "delta": [ 0.7951978824211975, -0.5234450102814989, 0.7473744594490088, 0.14859356758913925, -0.1384975706685253, 0.12705005159157856 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 144, "nfev": 30, "njev": 19, "initial_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "final_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 29.31809867719445, "optimality": 2.5803596984800583 }, "seconds": 0.2848113439977169, "population": [ { "points": 3783, "supported": 3783, "behind_over_20cm": 32, "in_front_over_20cm": 30 }, { "points": 3776, "supported": 3776, "behind_over_20cm": 30, "in_front_over_20cm": 28 }, { "points": 3780, "supported": 3780, "behind_over_20cm": 24, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.198528618914243, "translation_m": 0.047071714336865605, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "original", "condition": "exact_z_visible", "sign": 0, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.18268090104927648, -0.1232981698779414, 0.3218247264377875 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.016879329368267557, -0.025160497390676585, 0.009569397163537559, 0.9994951046648792 ] }, "delta": [ -0.09312755157030178, 0.09691136958134201, 0.043964307771944176, -0.01731909895072352, -0.02329816987794139, 0.021824726437787486 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 142, "nfev": 28, "njev": 19, "initial_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "final_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 41.32719391774292, "optimality": 0.5040346385231714 }, "seconds": 0.23704194099991582, "population": [ { "points": 3783, "supported": 3783, "behind_over_20cm": 15, "in_front_over_20cm": 35 }, { "points": 3776, "supported": 3776, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 36 }, { "points": 3780, "supported": 3780, "behind_over_20cm": 14, "in_front_over_20cm": 44 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.1414366889842183, "translation_m": 0.036319066510727235, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.1984423828746145, -0.1385226133864776, 0.32711680704870955 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.0159456856020603, -0.026108809907732625, 0.009270185689302863, 0.9994889338122599 ] }, "delta": [ -0.19819345342628059, -0.012120318888553331, 0.005097382502043554, -0.0015576171253855271, -0.0385226133864776, 0.027116807048709557 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 220, "nfev": 40, "njev": 30, "initial_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "final_support": [ 3783, 3776, 3780 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 29.31789808741207, "optimality": 3.7866723588809497 }, "seconds": 0.40590941499976907, "population": [ { "points": 3783, "supported": 3783, "behind_over_20cm": 32, "in_front_over_20cm": 30 }, { "points": 3776, "supported": 3776, "behind_over_20cm": 30, "in_front_over_20cm": 28 }, { "points": 3780, "supported": 3780, "behind_over_20cm": 24, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.19862858942095046, "translation_m": 0.04713532791601497, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "original", "condition": "exact_z_all", "sign": 1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.10051700554332485, -0.09984055124031661, 0.33471890150841316 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.018511123451446412, -0.020399511349073966, 0.012459938150654578, 0.999542869609186 ] }, "delta": [ -0.9327646245826202, 1.125706783502681, -0.36804043898552585, -0.24948299445667513, 0.1001594487596834, -0.06528109849158686 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 121, "nfev": 19, "njev": 17, "initial_support": [ 3803, 3802, 3807 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 183.1516008604836, "optimality": 0.004973541281641799 }, "seconds": 0.20643166000081692, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 365, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 140, "in_front_over_20cm": 50 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 400, "in_front_over_20cm": 55 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.7519335902958897, "translation_m": 0.1053674225362124, "recovered": false } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.19938031905770648, -0.14021400266954726, 0.32746715758580286 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.015832968771074107, -0.02615596716564642, 0.009137302074503561, 0.9994907164112747 ] }, "delta": [ -1.2169121677189445, 0.4666070829844306, -0.7709661259553795, -0.1506196809422935, 0.05978599733045276, -0.07253284241419716 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 186, "nfev": 36, "njev": 25, "initial_support": [ 3803, 3802, 3807 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 32.58876015568374, "optimality": 0.6982427609650769 }, "seconds": 0.3367795770027442, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 92, "in_front_over_20cm": 30 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 91, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 86, "in_front_over_20cm": 42 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.2116398706874858, "translation_m": 0.04870312886273246, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "original", "condition": "exact_z_all", "sign": -1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.10040438486658079, -0.10072692378290797, 0.3347521608610069 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.018483166943702264, -0.020395375223898404, 0.012457493027771625, 0.9995435018430517 ] }, "delta": [ 1.0806291792304739, 0.12430090283265695, 1.130099172955712, 0.05040438486658077, -0.10072692378290797, 0.1347521608610069 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 145, "nfev": 25, "njev": 20, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 183.14188124013214, "optimality": 0.03414822904513821 }, "seconds": 0.24549266499525402, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 365, "in_front_over_20cm": 42 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 140, "in_front_over_20cm": 51 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 402, "in_front_over_20cm": 56 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.7517987285625634, "translation_m": 0.10548709710907596, "recovered": false } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.19895680095898025, -0.14021160735172214, 0.32742342616095454 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.015829707628914978, -0.026135273334133947, 0.00917902623981621, 0.9994909270830936 ] }, "delta": [ 0.7820433261582581, -0.5253359207814111, 0.7373389484831673, 0.14895680095898023, -0.14021160735172214, 0.12742342616095453 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 173, "nfev": 35, "njev": 23, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 32.58976658928045, "optimality": 0.6058939086567097 }, "seconds": 0.3014819319942035, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 92, "in_front_over_20cm": 30 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 91, "in_front_over_20cm": 30 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 86, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.21179732771762302, "translation_m": 0.04868373375629261, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "original", "condition": "exact_z_all", "sign": 0, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.10043261321993599, -0.10059792470130634, 0.33461936416445753 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.018481988022831745, -0.020397459672748305, 0.012470553767924447, 0.9995433182440588 ] }, "delta": [ 0.07880965197215266, 0.6380783544558736, 0.39113278801963547, -0.09956738678006402, -0.000597924701306339, 0.034619364164457565 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 142, "nfev": 28, "njev": 19, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 183.1413452770001, "optimality": 0.15589308866327103 }, "seconds": 0.2731598429963924, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 364, "in_front_over_20cm": 42 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 140, "in_front_over_20cm": 51 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 402, "in_front_over_20cm": 55 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.752326292862017, "translation_m": 0.10541594945410597, "recovered": false } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.19876035581504203, -0.13834835938449094, 0.32700058074464944 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01595150418450866, -0.026129436298181163, 0.009253433099850581, 0.9994884571864037 ] }, "delta": [ -0.19745429815332768, -0.014447408408596414, 0.0031587121320813525, -0.0012396441849579752, -0.03834835938449094, 0.027000580744649477 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 163, "nfev": 31, "njev": 22, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 32.60297924958829, "optimality": 3.6794833344055173 }, "seconds": 0.34694081399356946, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 89, "in_front_over_20cm": 31 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 93, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 84, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.19800693787206797, "translation_m": 0.04691657218654949, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "near_foreground", "condition": "exact_z_visible", "sign": 1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.16674846784514577, -0.09940211720125995, 0.31837664468755855 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.017925999927984437, -0.024150496000125195, 0.008977813847392734, 0.9995072840795366 ] }, "delta": [ -0.9819886205784972, 0.7020258908091892, -0.776942510655731, -0.1832515321548542, 0.10059788279874006, -0.08162335531244144 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 179, "nfev": 35, "njev": 24, "initial_support": [ 3746, 3711, 3730 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 31.39054887335977, "optimality": 0.8500541150312695 }, "seconds": 0.31302778799727093, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 22 }, { "points": 3733, "supported": 3733, "behind_over_20cm": 5, "in_front_over_20cm": 33 }, { "points": 3754, "supported": 3754, "behind_over_20cm": 11, "in_front_over_20cm": 21 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.21741825221325917, "translation_m": 0.0379963540942958, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.1744615695575738, -0.10352032323172747, 0.32157036552724017 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.017546689858047672, -0.0249647949683339, 0.009146251486724832, 0.9994924805975062 ] }, "delta": [ -1.023767800905474, 0.6074137401643289, -0.7608350800524488, -0.17553843044242617, 0.09647967676827254, -0.07842963447275988 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 200, "nfev": 38, "njev": 27, "initial_support": [ 3746, 3711, 3730 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 23.235691870106777, "optimality": 0.12892096614721454 }, "seconds": 0.36648694399627857, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 28, "in_front_over_20cm": 18 }, { "points": 3733, "supported": 3733, "behind_over_20cm": 17, "in_front_over_20cm": 27 }, { "points": 3754, "supported": 3754, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 22 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.12186933645124616, "translation_m": 0.03361375870231166, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "near_foreground", "condition": "exact_z_visible", "sign": -1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.16675292002823036, -0.0994313538602945, 0.31837506316605313 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01792352004312897, -0.0241509348968736, 0.00897334765730818, 0.9995073580543025 ] }, "delta": [ 1.023267969950271, -0.29849120101205706, 0.721900575615076, 0.11675292002823034, -0.0994313538602945, 0.11837506316605313 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 230, "nfev": 44, "njev": 31, "initial_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 31.39052261672272, "optimality": 0.7644014507616278 }, "seconds": 0.3823540120065445, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 22 }, { "points": 3733, "supported": 3733, "behind_over_20cm": 5, "in_front_over_20cm": 33 }, { "points": 3754, "supported": 3754, "behind_over_20cm": 11, "in_front_over_20cm": 21 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.21738625511328827, "translation_m": 0.037991244141747864, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.17446387863370097, -0.10351947173150497, 0.32156794169572533 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01754683921328696, -0.02496497289316535, 0.009145816310695748, 0.9994924775135017 ] }, "delta": [ 0.9793190056164837, -0.391957132582982, 0.7392200021414106, 0.12446387863370095, -0.10351947173150497, 0.12156794169572534 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 179, "nfev": 35, "njev": 24, "initial_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 23.235691678201125, "optimality": 0.05885740289863974 }, "seconds": 0.2979688589985017, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 28, "in_front_over_20cm": 18 }, { "points": 3733, "supported": 3733, "behind_over_20cm": 17, "in_front_over_20cm": 27 }, { "points": 3754, "supported": 3754, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 22 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.12184860049044592, "translation_m": 0.03361035978226691, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "near_foreground", "condition": "exact_z_visible", "sign": 0, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.1667810716192587, -0.0994635091431511, 0.3183673368370606 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01792102373514539, -0.02415234555425702, 0.008969130891219396, 0.9995074065776443 ] }, "delta": [ 0.026808523243162376, 0.21469204987278853, -0.019520447047059814, -0.033218928380741315, 0.0005364908568489091, 0.01836733683706059 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 166, "nfev": 34, "njev": 22, "initial_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 31.390555851326706, "optimality": 2.298449829565563 }, "seconds": 0.264340503999847, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 22 }, { "points": 3733, "supported": 3733, "behind_over_20cm": 5, "in_front_over_20cm": 33 }, { "points": 3754, "supported": 3754, "behind_over_20cm": 11, "in_front_over_20cm": 21 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.21724267688158816, "translation_m": 0.037962403607916424, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.17705757596433608, -0.10337830483719014, 0.3218935108659238 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01754698477526381, -0.02507958672987371, 0.009185180413284096, 0.9994892446222375 ] }, "delta": [ -0.01562368691975128, 0.1076055574473462, 0.002184751720741099, -0.022942424035663943, -0.00337830483719014, 0.021893510865923817 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 137, "nfev": 23, "njev": 19, "initial_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3733, 3754 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 23.22433940754637, "optimality": 0.0106084471080238 }, "seconds": 0.22687683800177183, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 30, "in_front_over_20cm": 18 }, { "points": 3733, "supported": 3733, "behind_over_20cm": 17, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 }, { "points": 3754, "supported": 3754, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 22 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.10875611596261966, "translation_m": 0.031891904650577355, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "near_foreground", "condition": "exact_z_all", "sign": 1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.12172005025511376, -0.07806513642424273, 0.32789622906840554 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01960531693390017, -0.02048517229244512, 0.012134761990140073, 0.9995242552412187 ] }, "delta": [ -0.8064422709077278, 1.1189505905541006, -0.40040891162094294, -0.22827994974488622, 0.12193486357575728, -0.0721037709315945 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 265, "nfev": 49, "njev": 36, "initial_support": [ 3816, 3815, 3816 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 371.54624116197994, "optimality": 27.161518015380683 }, "seconds": 0.4365603629994439, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 373, "in_front_over_20cm": 36 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 302, "in_front_over_20cm": 48 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 434, "in_front_over_20cm": 40 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.7523064373885676, "translation_m": 0.08594817257153264, "recovered": false } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.1724747405265904, -0.10375954826928938, 0.32074296364947946 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.017550578007956282, -0.024879580172281104, 0.009097192800672104, 0.999494984872453 ] }, "delta": [ -1.0234080300008188, 0.6172892332644779, -0.7662702533071835, -0.17752525947340958, 0.09624045173071064, -0.07925703635052055 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 163, "nfev": 25, "njev": 23, "initial_support": [ 3816, 3815, 3816 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 26.95695270670912, "optimality": 0.011899526849059013 }, "seconds": 0.2883442449965514, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 98, "in_front_over_20cm": 18 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 122, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 104, "in_front_over_20cm": 23 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.13180066720434686, "translation_m": 0.03467051561819162, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "near_foreground", "condition": "exact_z_all", "sign": -1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.12078567767290706, -0.08032875554220535, 0.3300190953503419 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.019477529114639576, -0.020459690836908392, 0.01172586817424401, 0.9995321560240105 ] }, "delta": [ 1.1962436702809185, 0.11767743232073867, 1.0487474384914082, 0.07078567767290704, -0.08032875554220535, 0.13001909535034192 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 341, "nfev": 65, "njev": 46, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 371.5478434544116, "optimality": 8.848906392940181 }, "seconds": 0.5533588109974517, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 385, "in_front_over_20cm": 35 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 305, "in_front_over_20cm": 48 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 453, "in_front_over_20cm": 40 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.7306704929015488, "translation_m": 0.0869655840313386, "recovered": false } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.17247507556146585, -0.10375979329676832, 0.3207428200127833 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01755056290429303, -0.02487961136869805, 0.009097177234372058, 0.9994949845027995 ] }, "delta": [ 0.9799171838014447, -0.3820783856528855, 0.7338248261011496, 0.12247507556146583, -0.10375979329676832, 0.12074282001278336 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 143, "nfev": 23, "njev": 20, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 26.956952702821486, "optimality": 0.013497983242824762 }, "seconds": 0.24338391900528222, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 98, "in_front_over_20cm": 18 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 122, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 104, "in_front_over_20cm": 23 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.13179743533071434, "translation_m": 0.03467019026576237, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "near_foreground", "condition": "exact_z_all", "sign": 0, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.12018112462649601, -0.08110499194731477, 0.3312271082592434 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01943738058323578, -0.0204449648010489, 0.011580859948169825, 0.9995349295213286 ] }, "delta": [ 0.19039650458484286, 0.6352012620550452, 0.2926122432106485, -0.079818875373504, 0.01889500805268524, 0.031227108259243394 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 319, "nfev": 55, "njev": 44, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 371.5945011960339, "optimality": 26.646579369637035 }, "seconds": 0.5169253929925617, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 393, "in_front_over_20cm": 35 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 305, "in_front_over_20cm": 47 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 465, "in_front_over_20cm": 40 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.7243855488084244, "translation_m": 0.08776791261865871, "recovered": false } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.17247544909503856, -0.10375982887571705, 0.3207426175887567 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.017550563700841376, -0.024879644814050018, 0.009097166849398564, 0.9994949837508058 ] }, "delta": [ -0.015183894406917151, 0.13070276436301753, -0.0074885188055711085, -0.02752455090496145, -0.003759828875717043, 0.020742617588756736 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 145, "nfev": 25, "njev": 20, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 26.956952703535958, "optimality": 0.015685452807122698 }, "seconds": 0.24785013899963815, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 98, "in_front_over_20cm": 18 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 122, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 104, "in_front_over_20cm": 23 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.1317937087570231, "translation_m": 0.03466977646492532, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "staggered", "condition": "exact_z_visible", "sign": 1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.1906641883915072, -0.08603894338683157, 0.3166881605362584 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.018416489412306506, -0.025418099536886708, 0.009161514214377475, 0.9994652669257492 ] }, "delta": [ -0.9229873032933822, 0.5576282363674469, -0.7564570326736211, -0.15933581160849278, 0.11396105661316844, -0.0833118394637416 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 202, "nfev": 40, "njev": 27, "initial_support": [ 3745, 3744, 3746 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 46.88293943617805, "optimality": 3.200684872362643 }, "seconds": 0.3213512410002295, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 16, "in_front_over_20cm": 43 }, { "points": 3766, "supported": 3766, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 43 }, { "points": 3770, "supported": 3770, "behind_over_20cm": 24, "in_front_over_20cm": 31 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.10951194373194094, "translation_m": 0.02367621553857999, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.20743764686097985, -0.09365295279551614, 0.3212060841966735 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01779676501700563, -0.02660350110946663, 0.009158485992871057, 0.9994456718691449 ] }, "delta": [ -0.9908583631922547, 0.42025134869280045, -0.761669178885615, -0.14256235313902013, 0.10634704720448387, -0.07879391580332651 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 213, "nfev": 39, "njev": 29, "initial_support": [ 3745, 3744, 3746 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 31.163228305171558, "optimality": 0.9326579506694472 }, "seconds": 0.3599553759995615, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 26, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 }, { "points": 3766, "supported": 3766, "behind_over_20cm": 28, "in_front_over_20cm": 40 }, { "points": 3770, "supported": 3770, "behind_over_20cm": 36, "in_front_over_20cm": 30 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.06842551668812917, "translation_m": 0.023351693857212936, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "staggered", "condition": "exact_z_visible", "sign": -1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.19102528046852066, -0.08605621074369947, 0.31672637211254706 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01841448351731852, -0.02543162281507947, 0.0091604442255182, 0.9994649696809654 ] }, "delta": [ 1.078509742958762, -0.4458893026500394, 0.7417428150363391, 0.14102528046852064, -0.08605621074369947, 0.11672637211254708 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 209, "nfev": 41, "njev": 28, "initial_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 46.88195562613501, "optimality": 8.25335948805045 }, "seconds": 0.33713578501192387, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 16, "in_front_over_20cm": 43 }, { "points": 3766, "supported": 3766, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 43 }, { "points": 3770, "supported": 3770, "behind_over_20cm": 24, "in_front_over_20cm": 31 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.10836530072479648, "translation_m": 0.023553054441838993, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.20690408861940462, -0.09366480085602436, 0.32079049560473405 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01780396428125208, -0.026559908197632726, 0.00917228908296804, 0.9994465764838978 ] }, "delta": [ 1.0080987118096996, -0.574932262583177, 0.7395859026183328, 0.1569040886194046, -0.09366480085602436, 0.12079049560473408 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 220, "nfev": 40, "njev": 30, "initial_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 31.163601248358425, "optimality": 0.9600991443100881 }, "seconds": 0.3650368930102559, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 26, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 }, { "points": 3766, "supported": 3766, "behind_over_20cm": 25, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 }, { "points": 3770, "supported": 3770, "behind_over_20cm": 35, "in_front_over_20cm": 30 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.06369587333566325, "translation_m": 0.022804514801873958, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "staggered", "condition": "exact_z_visible", "sign": 0, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.19078917700995243, -0.08606173809381713, 0.31667354589752844 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.018414232477295053, -0.025423031324762316, 0.009159028837797751, 0.9994652058532506 ] }, "delta": [ 0.08418881007874604, 0.06916318433303792, 0.0011706188486504023, -0.009210822990047591, 0.013938261906182872, 0.016673545897528477 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 143, "nfev": 29, "njev": 19, "initial_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 46.8824283564383, "optimality": 3.3514815557444124 }, "seconds": 0.22287764099019114, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 16, "in_front_over_20cm": 43 }, { "points": 3766, "supported": 3766, "behind_over_20cm": 18, "in_front_over_20cm": 43 }, { "points": 3770, "supported": 3770, "behind_over_20cm": 24, "in_front_over_20cm": 31 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.10896124233482136, "translation_m": 0.023603422165362493, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.20684775452259124, -0.09416814687364966, 0.3207916672722979 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.01776024796794982, -0.026555572042677274, 0.0091965341645801, 0.9994472467043786 ] }, "delta": [ 0.010402383347188413, -0.0613634034509916, 0.0011849190375173172, 0.006847754522591233, 0.005831853126350347, 0.020791667272297944 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 183, "nfev": 39, "njev": 24, "initial_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "final_support": [ 3768, 3766, 3770 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 31.169554527822925, "optimality": 7.442641500974097 }, "seconds": 0.3048696860059863, "population": [ { "points": 3768, "supported": 3768, "behind_over_20cm": 26, "in_front_over_20cm": 41 }, { "points": 3766, "supported": 3766, "behind_over_20cm": 25, "in_front_over_20cm": 40 }, { "points": 3770, "supported": 3770, "behind_over_20cm": 36, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.062250253702945374, "translation_m": 0.022653822654266, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "staggered", "condition": "exact_z_all", "sign": 1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.16659417676782118, -0.06578178636049825, 0.3207040125414692 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.020129636693314325, -0.02346427906389005, 0.010380076408128642, 0.9994680982144295 ] }, "delta": [ -0.7350376537488797, 0.7828851245781596, -0.6055854011972536, -0.1834058232321788, 0.13421821363950176, -0.07929598745853081 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 152, "nfev": 32, "njev": 20, "initial_support": [ 3816, 3816, 3816 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 259.57095245271444, "optimality": 2.2246490667432637 }, "seconds": 0.24577077699359506, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 80, "in_front_over_20cm": 44 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 87, "in_front_over_20cm": 45 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 74, "in_front_over_20cm": 35 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.4287950654848508, "translation_m": 0.05211037618186494, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.2076493592532596, -0.0934524243312792, 0.32149681864425944 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.017804369226740845, -0.026634304323833822, 0.009115591959723458, 0.9994451081739543 ] }, "delta": [ -0.9897774916866365, 0.41683136576978613, -0.7666128982322882, -0.14235064074674036, 0.1065475756687208, -0.07850318135574057 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 238, "nfev": 46, "njev": 32, "initial_support": [ 3816, 3816, 3816 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 35.03324706163455, "optimality": 4.452443000025972 }, "seconds": 0.41002850100630894, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 98, "in_front_over_20cm": 42 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 102, "in_front_over_20cm": 38 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 106, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.07238510207857152, "translation_m": 0.023738084504593745, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "staggered", "condition": "exact_z_all", "sign": -1, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.16698246685019177, -0.06461920909829262, 0.3206063979706163 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.020223687097194087, -0.023433828746989366, 0.010617423906195049, 0.9994644208074881 ] }, "delta": [ 1.282653585525321, -0.2211890345033109, 0.9169120386660654, 0.11698246685019176, -0.06461920909829262, 0.12060639797061633 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 3, "message": "`xtol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 175, "nfev": 37, "njev": 23, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 259.5858750564841, "optimality": 34.051821387863576 }, "seconds": 0.2844054159941152, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 80, "in_front_over_20cm": 47 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 91, "in_front_over_20cm": 46 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 76, "in_front_over_20cm": 36 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.4475801407827992, "translation_m": 0.05259830318035408, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.20755027052865524, -0.09349510262113725, 0.3213135311961403 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.017804397540106886, -0.026625820782576356, 0.009110694970391655, 0.9994453783639426 ] }, "delta": [ 1.0083121119878706, -0.5823619902334941, 0.7323975923536583, 0.15755027052865522, -0.09349510262113725, 0.12131353119614034 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 4, "message": "Both `ftol` and `xtol` termination conditions are satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 216, "nfev": 42, "njev": 29, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 35.03317556572065, "optimality": 6.6504683407846645 }, "seconds": 0.3654491589986719, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 97, "in_front_over_20cm": 42 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 102, "in_front_over_20cm": 38 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 106, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.07149871147993475, "translation_m": 0.023528427210807397, "recovered": true } } } }, { "scene": "staggered", "condition": "exact_z_all", "sign": 0, "methods": { "symmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.16710528349291692, -0.06468472578948958, 0.3208921957173308 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.020216682518234785, -0.023454583072399195, 0.010581986998084185, 0.999464451509922 ] }, "delta": [ 0.2847582258984771, 0.29319088839720076, 0.1741827562241939, -0.032894716507083074, 0.03531527421051042, 0.020892195717330815 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 166, "nfev": 34, "njev": 22, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 259.5862370301528, "optimality": 18.68380654580678 }, "seconds": 0.2624725679925177, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 80, "in_front_over_20cm": 47 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 91, "in_front_over_20cm": 46 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 76, "in_front_over_20cm": 35 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.44399736588027916, "translation_m": 0.05259006378144224, "recovered": true } }, "asymmetric": { "result": { "transform": { "translation_m": [ 0.20753798725723407, -0.09344389127071834, 0.3213554034173073 ], "rotation_quat_xyzw": [ 0.017805932122302377, -0.026624229159347156, 0.009105498512959562, 0.9994454407819153 ] }, "delta": [ 0.015988103753134367, -0.06899826580691212, -0.009246393549271288, 0.007537987257234066, 0.0065561087292816626, 0.02135540341730727 ], "converged": true, "optimizer_success": true, "status": 2, "message": "`ftol` termination condition is satisfied.", "actual_residual_calls": 131, "nfev": 29, "njev": 17, "initial_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "final_support": [ 3840, 3840, 3840 ], "support_retained": true, "cost": 35.033329803732904, "optimality": 5.568840037776888 }, "seconds": 0.21999611100181937, "population": [ { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 97, "in_front_over_20cm": 42 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 102, "in_front_over_20cm": 38 }, { "points": 3840, "supported": 3840, "behind_over_20cm": 106, "in_front_over_20cm": 29 } ], "metrics": { "valid_output": true, "rotation_deg": 0.07142617077290847, "translation_m": 0.023576621231133323, "recovered": true } } } } ] }